Farm & Garden Education Challenges

What challenges are Farm & Garden Education programs facing in the Monadnock Region?

  • Prescribed curriculum
  • Not enough time to share the merits of outdoor and hands-on learning with decision makers
  • Lack of funding and time
  • Short growing season and long summer break
  • Not enough staffing to support program
  • Increased transportation costs
  • Lack of financial sustainability once grant funding ends
  • Difficult to find the right time to bring farmers, gardeners and educators together to share and learn new skills
  • Hard to pay farmers a fair price for their produce
  • Finding resources to support program (many organizations doing great work, but there is not once source of information for what groups are doing)

These challenges are certainly not unique to the Monadnock Region; but can a regional network help us focus to inspire collaborative thinking and identify solutions?

Building Relationships Between Kids, Kale, Curriculum & Community

By David Sobel, Antioch New England University, Core Faculty
Foreword to the Monadnock Farm & Garden Education Toolkit

A toolkit?  Looks like just a bunch of glossy pictures and words at first. Where are the packets of seeds, the trowel, the fork, the trusty hoe, the watering can? Well yes, you need all those things to actually plant a garden, but what if you are wanting to plant relationships?  Relationships between vegetables and children, between gardens and schools, between farms and communities? What kind of tools do you need then? To plant relationships, you need good stories, ways to get in touch with people, reasons to collaborate.  You need to know what it is you are going to get out of these new relationships, and how each new relationship will make the world a better place.

Remember how Miss Rumphius planted lupines all over the countryside to make the world a more beautiful place? Well, the Monadnock Farm and Community Connection’s folks, Meg, Bonnie, the Amandas, Jeff, Jen and Jessica, are all about making our corner of the world a healthier place through building relationships between kids, kale, curriculum and communities.

The Monadnock Region would be a better place for learning and living healthy lives if there was a garden at every school, a farm connected to every school lunch program and a farmer’s market every day of the week. If we believe in Vision 2020, the idea that our region’s communities will be the healthiest in the nation by 2020, then creating these relationships that engage all of us in growing and eating locally grown, healthy food is an integral part of that vision.

Each one of the stories in this toolkit can help you start to till the soil in your community. Learn how kindergarteners in Alstead, master gardeners in Keene and farmers in Winchester are all working to make tending and growing and harvesting a regular part of the air we breath every day. Learn how to help children throw off the shackles of their cell phones and savor the crunch of their celery. Learn how to seek out the fresh pressed and the just picked.

Take my hometown of Harrisville, for instance. I can buy locally raised lamb, pork, chicken, beef and yes, even goat from local farmers at The Harrisville General Store. (I admit, I was a bit leery of goat, but we tried it in moussaka and it was great.) We press our own cider from apples on my backyard trees or our neighbor’s wild trees. I can stop at Jody’s to pick up recently laid Silver Lake Farm eggs. Raised beds may be sprouting at the elementary school. The maple sugarer drops off a quart or two of syrup from the trees on my property that he is tapping. And just a few weeks ago, the old field in the triangle between the Harrisville and Nelson roads was tilled to make way for the new community garden next spring. Eleven of the twenty plots have already been claimed. My food is coming home again. Which is the way it should be.

Use this toolkit to plant relationships between your farm and the local school, between the community garden and the community kitchen, between children and good grades. All those relationships will make the Monadnock Region a more beautiful, and a healthier, place.

Antioch University: Building a Garden Community

Students plant peppers, tomatoes and basil.

Case Study 10

Enjoyable green spaces.  This is a topic on the forefront of many minds these days where school gardens are becoming a norm and the concept of edible landscapes is blooming.  At Antioch’s campus in Keene, NH, the lawn is now growing food for the on-site café  and is one of the most popular outdoor classroom spaces.

Four garden boxes, each two feet high and six feet long, create corners for an open space where people can sit and socialize, classes can meet, musicians can play, and inspiration can be derived.  In its first summer a variety of vegetables and herbs filled each bed, including peppers, tomatoes, basil, Swiss chard, pole beans, sweet peas, carrots, and much more!  This fall as leaves started to drop, produce was harvested, garlic was planted, and plans for winterization began materializing.  Throughout its first season students across departments combined efforts to create educational and funding sources, and the Antioch community as a whole is a buzz with excitement about the possibilities.

Project Beginnings

Antioch University New England is a unique location for a school garden.  It is a graduate school that caters to a wide range of disciplines including clinical psychology, integrated learning, environmental studies and more.  ANE values ecological stewardship and place-based learning experiences, and the creation of an on-site vegetable garden is an example of these values.

In March of 2009, a number of Antioch students, faculty and staff attended the workshop “Grow Food Everywhere” hosted by Deb Habib of Seeds of Solidarity.  Discussions following this workshop revolved around the desire to have a working, edible  landscape on Antioch’s campus.  A  few months later, the Antioch Garden Committee formed, a garden proposal was submitted to the campus president, and plans for construction were approved.

Work Study Students Sam and Jess get ready for a work party.

An Antioch student took the project on for her summer practicum and with loads of support hit the ground running.  By July 2009, four garden boxes were built and a variety of vegetables planted.  In the words of one volunteer, “Something beautiful has begun.”

Supplies for building the boxes were made available by local farms, students, faculty, staff and alumni.  Over $500 was collected through in-kind donations and a gift from the graduating class of the Environmental Studies department.  This provided the capital needed to buy the lumber and a few maintenance supplies.

Over 155 volunteer hours were committed to making this project a reality.  Currently there are two paid work study positions that coordinate the garden efforts and are supervised by a faculty member.  The garden is now able to use compost that is produced on-site from collected food waste and a center garden bed was created, which will host a garden of medicinal plants starting in the spring of 2010.

Up and Running

The theme of Antioch’s garden is truly “many hands make light work.”  Two garden coordinators host ‘work parties’ where everyone is welcome to come and participate in garden related events such as: planting garlic, harvesting produce, turning the compost pile, putting the beds to sleep for the winter, or participating in fundraising events.  The work parties have been an opportunity for new folks to meet each other, a great time to socialize after a day of classes, and an opportunity to take part in producing the food that is eaten on campus.

The first garden fund raiser, a sustainability themed book fair,  to raise funds for the purchase of materials for spring planting and project expansion was a campus-wide success.

Two different cold frames were built and more greens have been planted to extend the growing season and  provide an educational experience for overwintering with small, box gardens.  Students collaborate with the facilities staff as well as the landscaping crew to enhance the communication between different parties dedicated to preserving and maintaining the beauty and integrity of Antioch’s campus. The gardens are five months old now, and already students are incorporating the gardens into class curriculum and master’s projects – the medicinal garden being the first master’s project.

Hurdles to Overcome

There is concern that there may be gaps in leadership for the maintenance of the gardens from season to season or year to year because this is a student led initiative aligned with the school calendar and not the growing season.  Staffing the work study positions throughout the summer, the attraction of animals or rodents and the loss of open, green space have also elicited some concern from the Antioch community.  There is also a lack of continuous funding for project expansion.

Evaluation tools are being developed to help track this information. Small grants have been considered and more research is being done as to what is available, but there are few grants that cater to smaller scale, vegetable gardens at higher level institutions.  The location of the campus has also raised concerns about the soil quality for the gardens.  Soil tests were sent to UNH prior to planting, and the results did not indicate any threats to the health of the soil.  If the program hopes to expand to other areas of the campus, soil quality will need to be considered in those locations.

Planning for the Future

Students continue to express interest in using the gardens or garden space for class projects, faculty are considering how the gardens can be used as an experiential learning tool, and the committee hopes to expand the growth of food both for the purposes of the on-site café, as well as the local community kitchen.   Plans are being made to utilize the garden for classes such as Soil Ecology and Place-based Learning.  Entomology, a class held in the summer that studies

A garden inhabitant joining in on the building of the boxes.

the eight major orders of insects, could utilize the garden for observations.  Two students are currently planning a “Quest” that would have students finding items or investigating aspects of the garden and compost piles.

There are other students researching ideas for how new classes could be offered at Antioch including Eco-Therapy  and Sustainable Agriculture.  These visions for the future of the garden space are just at the tip of the iceberg. Student groups are beginning to brainstorm ideas for continuing to make our campus a “green” working landscape—and the expansion of the garden space on campus is a top priority.  Beautiful things truly are happening on ANE’s campus.

Advice for Other Schools/Projects

  • Allow for student-led initiatives to grow and find ways to help mobilize their efforts
  • Use human resources including friends, family, students, parents, local experts and community members
  • Stir up excitement for your project through brainstorming sessions and community forums
The Garden Committee and friends celebrating the completion of the box building.

Winchester School: Greenhouse, Garden, and Groundhog

Case Study 9

Behind the Winchester School, a greenhouse nestles along one of the building’s walls. Inside the structure you’ll find evidence of past gardening projects and the sweet smell of New Hampshire’s summer heat. The vents are open in hopes that plants will soon be growing there. Beside the greenhouse, raised bed gardens are home to a smattering of vegetables and other plants. Grasses and other weeds threaten to take over the space and this competition has only been fostered by plenty of rain and lots of sunshine this summer.

Herein lies one of the challenges to keeping up a school yard garden. Once students and teachers leave for the summer, who will tend to the growing crops? This and other topics will be brought to the table of the Winchester School Garden Committee meetings this fall. Despite meeting some daunting challenges early on in the gardening program, Jane Cardinale and her fellow horticultural comrades have the positive attitudes and determination to help this project blossom.

Project Beginnings

The garden program at Winchester School sprouted in 2007 from the desire of assistant principal Pam Bigelow and

Classroom garden plots at Winchester School.

local community members to foster a greater connection between students and the food they eat. A generous donation from a local couple provided the school with the materials they needed to get started—raised beds, a small greenhouse, seeds, etc. A garden committee, that consists of school administrators, teachers, and community members, was formed to guide all decisions about the school’s new garden space. Classrooms signed up to use the six raised bed spaces and were given free range of what they could create in these spaces.

Up and Running

To further enhance students’ involvement with growing their own food, an afterschool Garden Club was formed and another garden area was constructed. Teachers have attempted to tie the garden into the curriculum they are already teaching. For example, when fourth graders are learning about seeds, they use the garden as their classroom for part of this lesson. Six teachers have also gone beyond the boundaries of the garden to incorporate vermicomposting into their classrooms. All the worms were added to the garden at the end of the school year so to build the soil.

Hurdles to Overcome

One of the largest hurdles that Winchester School is working to overcome is the lack of garden maintenance in the summer months, when school is no longer in session. Another barrier faced is a lack of knowledge or experience with this type of programming among the staff. Last year the greenhouse got so hot that the plants inside were accidentally fried.  Those plants that survived the overheating were planted in the ground, only to be eaten by a pesky groundhog soon thereafter. Winchester school teachers have also found it to be a struggle to tie existing curriculum into the garden and greenhouse when time is limited.

Planning for the Future

In the coming years, the Winchester school would like to see their garden program grow in the following ways: improvements made to the gardens, utilize the greenhouse throughout the winter, start a composting program in the cafeteria, and begin garden fundraising. Like many new and existing school programs there is an enormous amount of work yet to do, yet the garden committee is excited to see what positive changes they can make in the years to come. First on the list to do next spring is to install a fence around the garden to protect the plants from the groundhog. Another new addition to Winchester School in the spring is an intern from Antioch New England. The graduate student’s time will be spent working with students and teachers, teaching lessons related to the garden and greenhouse to better integrate these resources into the school curriculum.

Advice for Other Schools/Projects

Jane Cardinale has only a few words of advice for other schools who are looking to start a similar school garden program:  Focus on crops that produce in the fall and spring.